Updates Made to Gambling Disorder Clinical Criteria Between DSM-III, DSM-IV, and DSM-5

Jul 8, 2023

Updates made to gambling disorder across the DSM-III, DSM-IV, DSM-5

The clinical evaluation and assessment of Gambling Disorder has changed since the DSM-III. Now in the DSM 5, Gambling Disorder has been updated for clinical interface with a new demographic and new modes of online gambling and online sports betting.

Gambling disorder is regarded as a complex and multifaceted condition (and set of behaviors) that has been a subject of significant attention in psychiatric classification systems. Since the legalization of online gambling and sports betting in 2018, further attention has been devoted to ensuring the clinical qualifications for gambling disorder are updated. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), published by the American Psychiatric Association, is amongst the primary references used by providers both nationally and internationally. The DSM has a long and varied history and aims to provide a standardized framework for diagnosing mental and behavioral health disorders. Here, our team examines the evolution of gambling disorder across the DSM-III, DSM-IV, and DSM-5 and explores the changes in diagnostic criteria and understanding of this specific condition.

DSM-III Categorization

DSM-III: In the third edition of the DSM (DSM-III), published in 1980, gambling disorder was not explicitly designated as a distinct clinical entity. Instead, it was categorized under "Impulse Control Disorders Not Elsewhere Classified." Despite its inclusion, this classification reflected a limited understanding of gambling and sports betting-related behaviors, the problems that may arise, and their underlying mechanisms. The diagnostic criteria primarily focused on impulse control issues and lacked a comprehensive characterization of gambling disorder.

Updates Between DSM-III and DSM-IV

DSM-IV: In the fourth edition (DSM-IV), published in 1994, gambling disorder took a significant step forward in terms of both recognition and classification. The DSM-IV introduced the diagnostic category of "Pathological Gambling" and included it within the category of "Impulse Control Disorders." This update from the DSM-III highlighted the problematic nature of gambling, and in turn, went about emphasizing the psychological and behavioral aspects of the disorder.

The DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for pathological gambling consisted of the following five criteria:

  1. Preoccupation: Frequent thoughts about gambling experiences.

  2. Tolerance: Needing to increase the amount of money wagered to achieve the desired excitement.

  3. Withdrawal: Restlessness or irritability when attempting to cut down or stop gambling.

  4. Escape: Gambling as a way to escape problems or negative feelings.

  5. Chasing: Repeated unsuccessful efforts to control, cut back, or stop gambling.

These criteria represented a significant step forward in recognizing gambling disorder as a distinct clinical condition. However, the DSM-IV criteria were criticized for primarily focusing on the behavioral aspects of gambling, neglecting the underlying psychological mechanisms involved.

How was Gambling Disorder changed for the DSM-5?

DSM-5: With the release of the fifth edition of the DSM (DSM-5), published in 2013, further revisions were made to enhance the diagnostic accuracy and clinical utility of gambling disorder. In turn, this empowered clinicians to better understand and diagnose gambling disorder. Among the updates to the DSM-5, gambling disorder was taken out of “Impulse Control Disorders" as a category and instead was  included in a novel classification entitled "Substance-Related and Addictive Disorders."

The diagnostic criteria for gambling disorder in DSM-5 expanded upon the previous edition and incorporated new elements. Crucial criteria to inform a diagnosis include:

  1. Persistent and recurrent problematic gambling behavior leading to clinically significant impairment or distress.

  2. Increasing need to gamble with larger amounts of money to achieve the desired excitement.

  3. Restlessness or irritability when attempting to cut down or stop gambling.

  4. Repeated unsuccessful attempts to control, cut back, or stop gambling.

  5. Preoccupation with gambling (e.g., reliving prior gambling experiences and at-risk gambling behavior, planning the next or ongoing gambling ventures).

  6. Gambling to escape or relieve negative emotions.

  7. Chasing losses (i.e., trying to win back previous gambling losses through further gambling).

  8. Deception regarding the extent of gambling involvement.

  9. Jeopardizing or losing significant relationships, job, educational or career opportunities due to gambling.

  10. Relying on others for financial assistance due to gambling losses.

  11. The diagnosis is not made if gambling behavior is better accounted for by a manic episode.

DSM-5 also introduced a severity specifier for gambling disorder, allowing clinicians to gauge the level of impairment associated with the condition. The severity levels are classified as mild, moderate, or severe, based on the number of diagnostic criteria met.

What’s Next for Further Classifications of Gambling Disorder?

The evolving understanding of gambling disorder across DSM-III, DSM-IV, and DSM-5 highlights the progressive recognition of this condition as a significant mental health issue. The transition from impulse control disorders to substance-related and addictive disorders reflects a growing understanding of the underlying psychological and neurobiological mechanisms involved in gambling disorder.

Throughout the changes made over the past 33+ years, the diagnostic criteria for gambling disorder in DSM-5 have become more comprehensive. As a result, the criteria now capturies a broader range of symptoms and their impact on individuals' lives. Additionally, the inclusion of a severity specifier enhances diagnostic accuracy, and aids clinicians in personalized treatment planning for gambling disorder. However as with all clinical criteria, ongoing clinical research and evidence-based clinical practice are necessary to continue refining the diagnostic criteria and improve the assessment and management of gambling disorder as well as how to recognize behaviors in individuals struggling with gambling and sports betting.

Clinical References:

  1. American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). American Psychiatric Publishing.

  2. American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). American Psychiatric Publishing.

  3. American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). American Psychiatric Publishing.

  4. Petry, N. M., Blanco, C., Auriacombe, M., Borges, G., Bucholz, K., Crowley, T. J., ... & Grant, B. F. (2014). An overview of and rationale for changes proposed for pathological gambling in DSM-5. Journal of Gambling Studies, 30(2), 493-502.

  5. Dowling, N. A., Cowlishaw, S., Jackson, A. C., Merkouris, S. S., Francis, K. L., & Christensen, D. R. (2015). Prevalence of psychiatric co-morbidity in treatment-seeking problem gamblers: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 49(6), 519-539.

The Science of Addiction

May 21, 2024

Jonathan

Family Therapy for Gambling Addiction

May 20, 2024

Jonathan

What is Residential Treatment for Gambling Addiction

May 17, 2024

Jonathan

Group Therapy for Gambling Addiction

May 16, 2024

Jonathan

Lottery Addiction: Guide to Help and Recovery 

May 15, 2024

Jonathan

Dialectical Behavior Therapy for Gambling Addiction

May 15, 2024

Jonathan

10 Gambling Addiction Quotes: From Realization to Recovery

May 14, 2024

Jonathan

Help For Family Members of Gambling Addicts

May 13, 2024

Jonathan

Essential Books on Gambling Addiction

May 11, 2024

Jonathan

Is Day Trading Legal?

May 4, 2024

Jonathan

Hypnotherapy for Gambling Addiction

May 3, 2024

Jonathan

Dangerous Gaming: Dave & Buster's introduces betting on arcade games 

May 2, 2024

Jonathan

The Relationship Between Problem Gambling and Suicide

Apr 30, 2024

Jonathan

Self Help for Gambling Addiction

Apr 29, 2024

Jonathan

Can poker become an addiction?

Apr 27, 2024

Jonathan

Naltrexone for Gambling Addiction

Apr 26, 2024

Jonathan

Understanding the Stages of Gambling Addiction

Apr 25, 2024

Jonathan

What Are The Negative Effects of Gambling

Apr 22, 2024

Jonathan

Gambling Addiction Intervention

Apr 20, 2024

Jonathan

Overview of 12-Step Program for Gambling Addiction 

Apr 19, 2024

Jonathan

Support Groups for Gambling Addiction

Apr 16, 2024

Jonathan

Managing Gambling Addiction Relapses

Apr 12, 2024

Jonathan

U.S. Sports Betting Statistics April 2024: Legalization, growth & addiction rising

Apr 12, 2024

Jonathan

My Mom Has a Gambling Addiction: What to Do

Apr 8, 2024

Jonathan

Understanding In-Network and Out-of-Network Providers for Behavioral Addictions

Apr 1, 2024

Jonathan

Has America become a “society of gamblers”?

Mar 28, 2024

Jonathan

How Can I Stop My Child From Gambling

Mar 27, 2024

Jonathan

Birches Health Partners with BettorEdge

Mar 20, 2024

Jonathan

Birches Health Announces Partnership with SaharaBets

Mar 19, 2024

Jonathan

Gambling Addiction Rates Hit All-Time High in U.S.

Mar 13, 2024

Jonathan

Signs of Teen Gambling

Mar 13, 2024

Jonathan

Free Gambling Addiction Treatment

Feb 29, 2024

Jonathan

SNL Sports Betting sketch spotlights real Gambling Addiction issues 

Feb 26, 2024

Jonathan

New U.S. Gambling Stats: Record figures as Addiction also grows

Feb 22, 2024

Jonathan

What will be the social costs of increased gambling? Who will pay them?

Feb 19, 2024

Jonathan

Is it Legal to Bet on the Daytona 500?

Feb 16, 2024

Jonathan

Media Takes Note of America's Increase in Problem Gambling

Feb 15, 2024

Jonathan

What are the Psychological Effects of Gambling?

Jan 31, 2024

Jonathan

Is Day Trading Gambling?

Feb 11, 2024

Jonathan

What are the Different Types of Gamblers?

Feb 12, 2024

Jonathan

Understanding Behavior Disorders

Jan 23, 2024

Jonathan

The Gambling Addiction Recovery, Investment, And Treatment (GRIT) Act

Jan 14, 2024

Jonathan

What is the Cycle of Addiction and How to Break It

Jan 9, 2024

Jonathan

I Lost All My Money Gambling. What Now?

Dec 29, 2023

Jonathan

Your 2024 New Year's Resolution: Stop Sports Betting and Online Gambling

Dec 24, 2023

Elliott

Why Do Addicts Relapse?

Dec 20, 2023

Jonathan

Is Gambling a Sin?

Dec 18, 2023

Jonathan

Staging a Gambling Intervention for a Loved One

Dec 13, 2023

Jonthan

Signs of Gambling Addiction in a Spouse

Nov 30, 2023

Jonathan

Gambling and Divorce: Statistics and Information

Nov 26, 2023

Jonathan

What is DFS Gambling?

Nov 19, 2023

Jonathan

Addiction Specialist: Helping You Overcome Addiction

Nov 18, 2023

Jonathan

Exploring the Different Types of Gambling

Nov 8, 2023

Jonathan

Technology Addiction: Signs and Treatment

Oct 30, 2023

Jonathan

Is Options Trading Gambling?

Oct 23, 2023

Jonathan

Gambling Addiction and Treatment

Oct 16, 2023

Jonathan

Sex Addiction Treatment and Therapy Options

Oct 14, 2023

Jonathan

Signs of Gambling Addiction

Oct 7, 2023

Jonathan

Is the Stock Market Gambling?

Sep 25, 2023

Jonathan

Tips for Finding a Gambling Rehab Center

Sep 24, 2023

Jonathan

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Pathological Gambling

Sep 23, 2023

Jonathan

What Causes Porn Addiction?

Sep 18, 2023

Jonathan

Video Game Addiction

Sep 16, 2023

Jonathan

Porn Addiction Signs & Symptoms

Sep 11, 2023

Jonathan

Gambling Addiction Withdrawal Symptoms & Signs

Aug 29, 2023

Jonathan

How to Stop Online Gambling

Aug 27, 2023

Jonathan

Does Medicare Cover Gambling Rehab?

Aug 19, 2023

Jonathan

Gambling and Dopamine

Aug 12, 2023

Jonathan

Porn Addiction Counseling

Aug 7, 2023

Jonathan

Is Fantasy Football Gambling?

Jul 24, 2023

Jonathan

Signs of a Day Trading Problem

Jul 19, 2023

Jonathan

Why is Gambling Addictive?

Jul 18, 2023

Jonathan

The Arizona Lottery and Gambling

Jul 16, 2023

Jonathan

Is Poker Gambling?

Jul 15, 2023

Jonathan

Is Crypto Gambling?

Jul 14, 2023

Jonathan

Gambling and Sports Betting Among College Students

Jul 8, 2023

Jonathan

Updates made to gambling disorder across the DSM-III, DSM-IV, DSM-5

Updates Made to Gambling Disorder Clinical Criteria Between DSM-III, DSM-IV, and DSM-5

Jul 8, 2023

Cara Anderson

Combatting Gambling and Alcohol Addiction

Jun 30, 2023

Jonathan

Medication for Gambling Addiction

Jun 27, 2023

Jonathan

The Seven Types of Gamblers: Are You One of Them?

Jun 25, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

10 Questions to Ask If You Think Your Loved One Has a Gambling Problem

Jun 24, 2023

Cara Anderson

Las Vegas - often called the gambling capital of the world

Exploring the History of Gambling in the US

Jun 17, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

Gambling Treatment in Arizona

Jun 15, 2023

Jonathan

Voluntary Self Exclusion to Stop Online Gambling

Jun 15, 2023

Cara Anderson

Does Blue Cross Blue Shield Cover Gambling Treatment?

Jun 13, 2023

Jonathan

Gambling Addiction Hotline

Jun 5, 2023

Jonathan

How to Stop Gambling

Jun 1, 2023

Jonathan

Can Gambling Addiction Be Cured?

May 31, 2023

Jonathan

problem gambler worried about addiction

Why Is Gambling So Addictive?

May 30, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

Medication that can cause gambling

Abilify and Compulsive Gambling

May 26, 2023

Jonathan

A man who has regained control of his life by stopping gambling and online sports betting

How to Stop Gambling: Strategies for Regaining Control

May 21, 2023

Cara Anderson

This man stopped gambling by recognizing his online sports betting problem

How to Stop Gambling and Save Money

May 18, 2023

Cara Anderson

People celebrating being free of a gambling addiction

How to Help Someone with a Gambling Addiction

May 16, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

The Growing Phenomenon of Cryptocurrency Addiction: What Traders Need to Know About Crypto Addiction

Cryptocurrency Addiction

May 9, 2023

Tobias Jackson

The stock market graph of a day trader who has a day trading addiction

How Day Trading Can Create a Dangerous Addiction

May 4, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

Younger individuals gathered around a computer talking about a gambling addiction meme

How Addictive Memes Have Fueled Problem Gamblers

May 2, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

Man in the middle of taking a Do I have a Gambling Problem Quiz

Clinical Screening Tools and Quizzes to Answer the Question: "Do I have a Gambling Problem?"

May 1, 2023

Tobias Jackson

Insurance paperwork that Birches clients do not need to go through as Birches Health handles all administrative and payment matters for them!

Insurance Coverage for Gambling Addiction in 2023

Apr 29, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

Couple hugging as the man has a gambling addiction and the woman, his loved one, is able to support him through it.

Helping a Loved One with a Gambling Addiction

Apr 27, 2023

Cara Anderson

Man actualizing self care and manifesting his recovery journey from problem gambling and gambling addiction

Self Care for Problem Gamblers

Apr 26, 2023

Cara Anderson

Bad effects of glamorization of gambling in the media in films, tv shows, and podcasts

Glamorized Gambling and What To Be Aware Of

Apr 24, 2023

Elliott Rapaport

Therapist offering a problem gambler gambling addiction counseling and treatment

What is Problem Gambling?

Apr 20, 2023

Elliott Rapaport